_
RobertoLofaro.com - Knowledge Portal - human-generated content
Change, with and without technology - human, AI, scraping readers welcome
for updates on publications, follow: on Instagram, Twitter, Patreon, YouTube


_

You are here: Home > Diritto di Voto / EU, Italy, Turin > How to crash land: three cases- France, Italy, Stellantis

Viewed 4528 times | Published on 2026-10-04 07:30:00 | words: 6151



This article is within the EU, Italy, Turin series.

Tomorrow, within my monthly post for my Eastern European community, will share an update narrative on the articles published since mid-September.

This article will be more a sharing of considerations and a signpost across time, than an analysis- anyway, will share material to allow further reading, if interested.

Why "crash landing"? Crash landing is landing nonetheless- not smooth, something that you would like to avoid, but better than nose-diving into the land.

It is an unplanned event, but sometimes it is the better alternative than no alternative.

Sometimes, you need to initiate such an emergency landing as a nudge, to generate an incentive to change.

Example: an Italian politician while in office during the oil crisis of the early 1970s had one lamppost out of two switched off, to signal the need for energy savings.

Decades later, he admitted that the move did not save any money- actually generated costs, but was to signal to structurally individualist Italians the need to save energy, as otherwise each and every one of them would consider that saving energy would be something that they as individuals could excused from.

In Italy, the need to more or less dramatic "nudge" to generate incentives to change is a routine- and since I was a kid frankly always saw this kind of paternalistic "we know better" approach to administration and interaction with citizens- then, found funny how routinely politicians complained about lack of interest for the "commons" by citizens.

Leadership should also educate and leave behind a better place than they found, not just float around to avoid displeasing anybody- and, in tribal Italy, any choice is going to displease somebody.

Developing a shared long-term interest is more complex than using instantaneous "nudges" to motivate.

I am boring- one of those people who, even as a consultant, after a meeting, unless there is a banner stating not to do so, after everybody leaves a meeting room switches off the lights.

Or that, when finds an open faucet with running water, again unless there is a writing stating not to touch it, closes the faucet.

And other similar activities.

The concept? energy, water, space are in my view a "common"- which is more than just a shared resource- is a resource that we have been temporarily assigned, but whose use should be sensible to cover not just for our generation, but also for future generations.

Notably because, often, at least since WWII, we leave behind for future generations the maintenance costs of badly designed and cheaply developed quickly delivered infrastructure built for our own purposes, not for a long-term concept.

And not just in Italy or the European Union.

As for the concept of "common"- what I wrote above should be, in my view, extended to what makes the overall market economy that we selected to use as our system to work properly.

Since the beginning of this century, on the natural resources, financial architecture of our society, and physical infrastructure (to name just a few elements) we have been routinely confronted with the side-effects of our collective short-term approach- and we are starting to reap, all across different domains, the consequences.

Be it the financial crisis of two decade ago, or the realization due to a couple of tsunamis around a decade ago of how much our world is interlocked and with no resilience if a single point of failure fails, to say nothing about the 2020-2021 COVID crisis and its side-effects.

We have been restructuring and fixing using a tinkering approach ("least resistance") for a couple of decades.

So far, with really razor-thin successes: as even the recovery and resilience facility, those 750bln EUR set in motion by the European Union during the COVID crisis, frankly focused more on "recovery" than "resilience" (and investment), and the "NextGenerationEU" was more a paper tiger and good for events and leaflets, than a real choice in prioritization of funding allocation.

As shared in previous articles, France and Italy few years ago signed the "Quirinale Treaty", with followed the footsteps of the 1963 "Elysée Treaty" between France and Germany.

It is curious how in 2026 these three key Member States of the European Union started, first with elections in parts of Germany, followed by further elections to come in Italy and France, to have a similar pattern of reconsideration of the "status quo"- internally, and in their relationship within the European Union.

Stellantis is the third element within the title- and not just because one of the companies that was merged within Stellantis in 2021, FCA, in turn had been merging the former FIAT and Chrysler, FIAT being the company that qualified my birthplace, Turin, as a "company town".

Stellantis absorbed companies that, in turn, absorbed key players in the automotive industry in various EU Member States- including France, Italy, and Germany.

As will be shared later in this article, media reported that the company lost 60% of its market value in few months, and routinely announced recently that some of its plants would either be shut off, temporarily idled, or given to others to use as production facilities.

Pull the plug on that and, considering that automotive in Europe, as shared in the past, it still "the industry of industries" and generates the infrastructure and capabilities that could help also for the new European defense posture, this could undermine more than just the existing automotive per se.

You can actually look on both my Facebook and Linkedin profiles for contributing news items that posted online across the last few weeks (well, say- months) about the concepts within this article- and more posts will come.

Still, as we are starting the last quarter of 2026, wanted to have a collection of points before moving forward with other articles- and news this week actually helped (as usual) to identify points worth looking at and remembering.

As you probably know, recently started a series about forthcoming national elections in Italy, but with an eye also on the European side, "The Cospaia of Europe", and another series on change within the European Union, "The Future of Europe".

I will share tomorrow that September has been a busy writing month- as I had a procrastination of activities that were supposed to start, and therefore decided to dig more into some knowledge updates and preparation of something else.

This last quarter of 2026 started really in August, with some seismic noises coming both from endogenous, EU-generated issues, and the obvious external pressure.

Exogenous pressure from the ongoing and potentially extending conflict that followed the invasion of Ukraine, which is already shifting gradually the European Union toward a war economy, to the continued entropy generation from both PM Netanyahu to keep being in office whatever it takes and President Trump working really on avoiding a potential mid-term win of the opposition that could affect not just his presidency, but also what built across it.

As the title of that 2022 movie went Everything Everywhere All at Once.

Actually, there is a one year old research summary from Rand.org that is worth reading as a bit of contextualization: "Consequences of the Russia-Ukraine War and the Changing Face of Conflict"

And after this long introduction, few short sections about "crash landing", and my conclusions- through sharing some news items corroborating the narrative.

The table of contents:
_ A_Italy- hopes and procrastination
_ B_France- (social) debt and political opportunism
_ C_Stellantis- how to dismantle an industry
_ Conclusions and next steps



A_Italy- hopes and procrastination

On my Facebook and Linkedin profiles, you can find, across the months, plenty of commentary about the Italian national debt and budget, including the pressure an election cycle applies on our public finances.

Actually, a summary is within a recent article The Cospaia of Europe: introduction and fence-sitting announce

I previously shared online that not getting under the 3% for now was a blessing in disguise- as we are "forced" to avoid doing the usual "earmarking" that is an annual tradition in Italy, but becomes a moveable feast (to quote an American writer in Paris) before any election.

A recent issue of a weekly Italian magazine has the title "I cavalieri della mancia"- with the President of the Council of Minister Meloni represented as Don Qijote and her two vice-presidents on donkeys at her side.

Well, the cover is an obvious attack on the government, but the articles inside are more balanced- "dare la mancia" in Italian means "tipping", but it is closer to the French "pourboire" or, a was told once in London "give them a fiver for a pint" (for public work employees who were coming to do a work).

The articles within the magazine actually tell the story of plenty of past cases covering all the different shapes of government: left, center, center-left, center-right, not just the incumbent one.

Some of my readers in Brussels probably remember how, while living there, as I had been asked from my usual pub contacts some information about the forthcoming Italian budget, I promised to write a detailed commentary on the initial year-end government decree, and then also the ensuing conversion into law.

Well, did the former, that was I think around 90 pages long- then apologized for not doing the latter, as adding all the earmarks expanded the resulting law in over 300 pages.

And that too is a routine: too many tribes, too many interests to compound.

Few days ago, shared online at article stating that Italy has to refinance by year end 100bln 100bln EUR.

So, what I wrote in recent articles and posts was actually confirmed across all the media- but also by the Minister assigned to that portfolio of activities himself:



The numbers:



Italy is a curious country: as my Latvian friends told me in Latvia few decades ago, they usually met Italians who either found no fault about our country ("we are the best ") or complained that nothing worked, even when told of real cases of what happens when nothing works- at a time when I asked why the had retirees protesting in a central square in Riga, and was told that they were those who had retirement benefits in rubles, that now had all the prices in a currency pegged, for historical reasons, to the British Pound.

So much that, when I asked again (yes, I am the one who asks questions) why so many of them had bags of bananas (relatively expensive in Italy), was told that they themselves, not yet an EU Member State, called themselves "banana republic", as, due to a commercial war, bananas were redirected to them instead of Europe, and therefore was a cheap food staple that retirees could afford.

In my case, they said that I was unusual because talked about lights and shadows and potential improvements in Italy (and, actually, they themselves provided some "shadows" from interactions with our bureaucracies, unfortunately, both then and in mid-2000s, when we met in Rome and then, in 2007, returned the visit by meeting them again in Riga).

And unusual it is, even in Italy.

Because Italy is a tribal country: if your (main) tribe says that everything is going bad with the current government, it is expected for you to align.

Ditto if your tribe states that under its leadership the situation is improving (no Italian, except when meeting foreigners, would say that everything is fine in Italy, so no tribe tries to say so).

And if you are bipartisan, do not belong to any tribe, and dare to approve individual measures proposed or adopted by a tribe?

At best, you find tribes that assume that you are switching toward them.

And, when it happens few times with few tribes, as I saw first end since the late 1990s first in Turin, then in Rome, then with Italians abroad and from 2012 back in Italy...

... obviously you are considered a basket case- if you could actually contribute something to a tribe.

Or naive if you are considered harmless.

Only to then see the obnoxious Italian habit of courting when proved right and become useful to sort out the mess that their own champions developed.

As said to my foreign contacts already in the 1990s: beware of when Italians become too kind and lavish praise- usually, they have something in mind- to quote a 1990s book "a monkey to move onto your shoulder", i.e. the style "I have an issue. Here it is. If you need, I can help you with it".

Hence, you understand why another annoying Italian habit is never to be the first to raise an issue, as otherwise it becomes your issue to solve.

In business, careers in Italy often are built on surfing, not taking on challenges- but will explain in the closing section by using the "three project managers for a project or initiative" paradigm.

Now, we Italians have an inclination to generating tribal issues that would then fester into systemic issues, and then try (unsuccessfully) to solve them through tribal ways.

One of the first times I heard Italians abroad react to something I wrote by stating that I was hallucinating and other theorems and assorted insults was while living in Brussels, a couple of decades ago.

The "crime"? The Italian national debt was less than half what is now- and I dared to utter that, if my fellow Italians kept having their tribal way, would soon add few hundred billions and reach 2,000- and then I we would see what they would do.

Well, it is over 3,000 now- but I was too "foreigner", i.e. pessimist: after 2,000bln Italian governments kept playing musical chair- too many tribes, nobody willing to displease anybody.

Solutions? Yes, but not so popular- and while shared some points from the business side in the past, frankly, there will be a time and place in the future.

For now, let's see if that "keep calm and do not overspend" from the Minister (should make t-shirts with that motto to spread around to other ministers and the opposition leaders) will keep the boat steady until January 2027.

Now, France too has an issue with debt- but, more significant, an issue with political alternatives.



B_France- (social) debt and political opportunism

When worked in Italy for a French company in the early 1990s, eventually as a "cadre", and then again when worked in Paris for an American company in the late 1990s, and, finally, when, while living in Brussels in mid-2000s to early 2010s, lived in Brussels and frequently went to Paris, had a chance of seeing life in Paris and in France first-hand.

As an individual, and as a business- and talk with and observing locals.

I remember in the late 1990s some protests from people who, being long-term unemployed, protested to have, as employees, also an amount equivalent to that given to employees at year end.

And also met some that had been living on subsidies for generations.

Even worse, it was a trap that you could not escape: when interviewing people, the address gave away from which area they were.

I remember once, traveling by Thalys from Brussels to Paris in the evening, seeing the train slowing down: the peripheral areas we went through were lighted up by fires.

Then I discovered that somebody had died, and riots ensued.

While working in Paris, I had for weeks a surprise strike on the RER each morning- as a ticket controller had been assaulted, and personnel wanted to have a police escort on each train.

So, it was a brewing ground for the extreme right.

Now, over the last few presidential elections across few decades, first the father Le Pen then the daughter have been the common enemy that generated a coalition of "provided that it is not Le Pen".

Without really removing the underlying causes of that electoral success.

Melenchon and his La France Insoumise practically acknowledged that he had limited chances of winning the next presidential elections.

So, the second best was to build a strong electoral base.

Ended up doing his best to bring water to the Le Pen cohort.

Not unusual, for extremists of the left and the right to de facto join forces, in this case also to avoid, for Melenchon, that anybody more moderate could challenge his leadership on the left.

Usually, in French I read Le Monde and Le Monde Diplomatique.

In this case, found more interesting to share material from Le Figaro and a business newspaper.









There is also another underlying issue: the national debt- specifically, its control.

Italy under this government (I have never voted for any of the political parties of the coalition) was able to achieve a temporary improvement- but the latest news show a 2026 respite, but then a 2027 increase, and a potential reduction in 2028.

Meaning: does not matter who wins the next elections- matters what will happen next, and for now 2027 is a collection of uncertainties.

So I will close with a short excerpt from an editorial (translated by the website):
"Tick-tock, tick-tock... The financial bombshell is brewing, it's running rampant."
By Jacques-Olivier Martin
Published on 02/10/2026 at 8:05 PM

The fight against the runaway growth of our public spending is no longer negotiable. It must be established as an absolute priority for our parliamentarians and our presidential candidates.

The financial crisis is brewing, it's spreading . And France has never been so close to the precipice. In less than three days, two figures have illustrated this loss of control, which is rapidly pushing our country toward a cataclysmic crisis. First, the debt ratio. It has never been so high in eighty years, now comparable to that of the post-war period, when France was exhausted and in need of rebuilding. Second, the interest rate. It is nearing 5%, a level not seen for over two decades. The first reveals our inability to control spending, to stop this headlong rush. The second reflects the growing distrust of our creditors in the face of our refusal to tackle the problem.
" (read it here)

So, it seems that the potential is to have a President either from the extreme-right (that is now trying to show to be at least in economy moderate) or right-of-center, with a significant bloc on the extreme left: sounds not really a way to ensure stability.



C_Stellantis- how to dismantle an industry

Within the Italian and French post elections scenario, what will happen to the automotive champion of both countries (with a component, to stay in Europe, also in other European Union Member States)?

I shared in past articles since 2025 what expected- and, often, again as usual the commentary from Turin was that I was either wrong or lunatic or worse.

Until proved repeatedly right: signal intelligence implies reading the signals for what they are, not for what you would like them to be (or even to mean).

From the time right before the announce of the current CEO, to the first announces (e.g. when was disclosed both his salary and the "capped" severance), looked more like a transition than a relaunch.

Why automotive is critical for Italy and France, and certainly highly critical for Turin and Piedmont (the region of Turin)?

Remember: not by chance automotive was defined the "industry of industries"- and shared in part articles why covered the critical role that e.g. in the USA covered the military-industrial complex.

Supply chains, logistics, productions of components and electronics, distributed maintenance facilities, educational institutions training engineers, etc: all depend on the volume of demand that, until recently, generated the mass-production of vehicles for private use.

Commercial vehicles, trucks, or even military vehicles could not match that, as will be discussed later.

Adopting the new defense posture for the European Union requires a level of industrial development and (continuous) volume that so far only automotive provided.

From research and innovation, to production, to distribution, to associated financial services and support services.

As remembered on October 1st by Commissioner Kubilius in Brussels (see the recording here: "Committee on Security and Defence Extraordinary Meeting: Exchange of views with Commissioner Kubilius")...

... logistics is critical.

In Europe, logistics means the whole automotive/transportation supply chain- remember also how highways in Germany generated almost a century ago the first large highway network that we currently take for granted.

I remember how in the early 1990s, while visiting my German girlfriend who worked a Stadtplännerin in a small town, she was fond of showing me small villages with large roads- as taxes on auto, until then could be used for that purpose, and were just starting to allow use for anything from parking to surrounding areas.

Stellantis is influenced by what happens in both Italy and France- and has a significant (yet fading) industrial role in at least four key European Union Member States: Italy (including my birtplace, "the European Detroit", i.e. Turin), France, Germany, and, due also to recent choices from Chinese partners, Spain.

From a cultural and organizational change perspective, it was curious to read that, at a time when the company was reported having lost 60% of its market value, as a measure to recover was announced the deployment of 50 war rooms:



If done just for internal needs, sounds more as an act of frenzied desperation, than a roadmap for change.

Frankly, made me think when in an interview stated that "was having a blast" being a CEO, not too long before announcing an over 20bln charge.

If a CEO in a year loses that much, usually it is the time for the three envelopes joke that was told first long, long ago.

An incoming CEO received three envelopes left from his predecessor, to open in each successive year of tenure:
_ in the first, it is written "blame me"
_ in the second, it is written "it is your fault"
_ in the third, it is written "prepare the three letters for your successor".

Anyway, jokes aside, could be a controlled crash landing preparing for other operations.

These are the data from a local newspaper:



Recently, other news started preparing a shift in focus.

For now, the communication campaign started recently highlighted how Stellantis has become marginal within Exor's portfolio, and communication shifted to other activities.

From new funding for the family football club, Juventus, to the availability of liquidity for new investments, to initiatives on startups and new technologies:



Losing 60% of the market value while retaining infrastructure after having written off a significant value, plus finding new partners to reuse that infrastructure turned Stellantis into a cheaper acquisition or merger target- as shared in previous posts on Linkedin, real estate management more than manufacturing.

Anyway, the 22bln charges announced on 2026-02-06 could entitle to do something on the line of what recently BMW announced, bypassing political and (in Italy) tribal opposition:



Redesigning the whole organization, notably if, due to the loss of market value, the most significant shareholder with direct political impacts, the French State, after having had a year without dividends (see the February 2026 press release above), under a new political majority, might have other interests (list of the top 10 shareholders, from MarketScreener):



I remember that in 2005, when visiting a former customer, was told that were firing managers by the dozens- monthly.

As I wrote in that Linkedin post above, having 50 war rooms at the same time could be a distraction and absorb significant resources away from operations.

Will be interesting to see how things will evolve, and, notably, how the transition will be managed.

If done properly, could imply repurposing, retraining, and designing new processes and organizations.

Because shifting in 2026 from one production type to another one does not imply copying e.g. the processes that have been used since the 1950s in the USA military-industrial complex: as shown in that post about BMW, implies identifying also which steps really require human intervention, and which steps could be automated with a degree of freedom and a defined escalation and oversight process (i.e. AI, as in the process and structure within my AI2AI communication protocol experiment).

Now, for those who still sell the dream that defense could replace in zero time the mass-production of civilian vehicles: look at how many Jeeps were produced during WWII:



To close on a positive note, yesterday's quote from Elkann about Marchionne:



I will not share here which scenarios I think are more probable: it will be for later times.

For now, as I wrote within the introduction, the idea was to share signposts.



Conclusions and next steps

In the early 1990s, one of my selling point for cultural and organizational change first, then methodologies, and then again change but evidence-based (i.e. integrating data in decision-making, as did from the late 1980s for customers), was that change should be considered a continuum, not a crisis-to-crisis activity.

Something that implies building a special type of capabilities: an attitude to change as a stepping stone, not an achievement.

Something that, incidentally, would convert any initiative in that direction, successful or not, into a learning lesson.

Instead of the usual scapegoating exercise at the end, with its companion identification of somebody to collect the pieces prepared by the scapegoat, and raise from the assembled debris as a winner.

As shared in the past, in project management, when intervening to recover activities, sometimes when working as facilitator or account manager I had to cheer up the actual project manager.

So, I explained the overall social dynamics of many projects where the initial business case and scope definition let's say that is a bit too superficial.

The first project manager is the one that actually tries to make it work- and, in the process, fixes the business case, scope, and gets the blame for the results.

The second project manager, inheriting expectations but at least vague understanding of the issues, is called in to solve- and, first, has to hit the ground running, assess, and pave the way to actually bring it back on a route that deliver completion.

Still, in many cases, what the second project manager reports is not necessarily something that management wants to hear, so a third project manager is involved.

This time, there third project manager inherits:
_ what the first encountered as roadblocks and preparedness issues
_ what the second assessed and identified as potential fixes (and risks to manage)
_ most important, if the project or initiative is still floating, a willingness from management to have some sort of conclusion.

Including by finding somebody to take the blame for all the changes and mistakes across, allowing the third one to complete into a success.

Of course, there would often be quite a change between the initial that was assigned to the the first project manager and what is assigned to the third project manager.

Anyway, generally the third one is able to swiftly deliver courtesy of what the second did, and claim a success.

Personally, often I have been called to be the second and continuing as the third- and, in some cases, of course the second: just the role of the third is usually assigned to somebody who is coopted into fast-track, hence has to receive a support network and ready-made successes.

If you ever worked in large consulting companies, it happens actually that, depending on business politics needs, either on your side or the customers' side, you can be asked to play one of the three roles- and a different one in different initiatives.

Two elements change significantly since the late 1990s, in my experience:
_ technological change accelerated and expanded the amount of information, not necessarily its quality
_ in most cases, the managerial capabilities are still developed not just as was pre-Internet, but even before computing was available on each desk (i.e. PCs).

Add to that volatility and easier access to even more data in shorter timeframes, and you build up uncertainties.

The second point in that list above becomes then even more critical than in the past: if you train and prepare your managers for their ability to navigate corporate politics, not for delivery with a systemic perspective, you generate incentives for tunnel vision- and spending so much time and resources hedging, that decision-making becomes at best convoluted.

And anything but timely, and certainly not pre-emptive.

Meaning: the rotation between first-second-third might be detrimental (albeit I keep see it still used), as each "handover" has a phase-in and phase-out.

Not for the project manager (that could be reduced to zero- and I had cases where frankly barely met the previous project manager), but for the time, that has to adjust to different styles of communication, and different operational cultures.

So, in our times, probably it is better to have just one that covers the three phases- notably because too many "agile" initiatives and projects frankly actually are "superficial" or a bit "hurried up": as they say about using AI, better to think before you start prompting, as otherwise you get dragged into rounds upon rounds of something that, if you had spent some time thinking, you would have simply avoided starting at all.

Or, at least, would have been subject to iterations and increments not of the product or service or benefit delivered, but of the original intent, well before you started even building a roadmap.

Couple old approaches and new times, and you get so often what Orwell called in "1984" and described in the appendix as "newspeak", that you barely ever notice it.

Some roadmaps are so superficial, that could frankly be generated by the dozen from your favorite AI in a single day.

Then, trying building the needed capabilities to deliver, a mere exercise of capacity planning, and to deliver even just a first couple of iterations of the first increment that you want to be the result, and you will see how easy is obfuscating your way into a rabbit hole.

And no, I am not referring to the inflated descriptions common on Linkedin, that generated countless memes (e.g. look on Linkedin how to describe that you changed a lightbulb).

I am referring to euphemisms so common that you start missing the irony of it.

The European Union has an issue with communication: we praise transparency, but then obfuscate in language assuming that that would be enough to avoid disclosing too much.

And end up with something that frankly is astonishingly open.

Such as this case:



There is another issue, that you will see if you read my latest half a dozen of articles: we confuse "seed-level" resources with investment.

In Italy, I am quite used to that concept, and, coming from Turin, routinely we use car-related metaphors, as in this post where shared a post from somebody else:



Even when using a "crash landing" approach, you need to consider the capabilities and resources needed.

In this article shared signposts about Italy and France, and then compounded with Stellantis.

I hinted a bit at my assessment in each one of those three cases- but, frankly, I think that it is better to let that for future articles.

Anyway, what you read so far is aligned with my approach in publishing: as a bipartisan observer, I share what I assess based upon the information that I have from public sources that even those reading can access.

As a complement to the signposts shared so far, I suggest to read a volume from the Italian geopolitical magazine Limes, specifically L'Italia nella rivoluzione mondiale, released in February 2026.

Nominally, is about Italy- but in reality you will find different "circles of influence"- first, our European partners (notably France and Germany), then our enigmatic (under President Trump- but, frankly, since the 1990s) ally USA, and then China and Russia.

Interesting reading...

... and have a nice week!